Zoho Polls > Does force exist?
Home  Tags  Feedback  
  Home > Does force exist?
 
Search
 
Export Results as CSV
Does force exist?
 
 
Yes    
No    
Show Results 
Tags : force newton physics exist  
 
8 Comments  ( Add )   
 Pioneer1 said on June 19, 2007 @ 05:44 PM ( 530 days ago )
Please leave a comment why you chose yes or no. Thanks
 guest said on June 19, 2007 @ 07:52 PM ( 530 days ago )
Force does not exist because it was never observed in a scientific experiment.
 Carl Brannen said on June 23, 2007 @ 11:14 PM ( 526 days ago )
When I had completed my first year graduate classes in physics, I mentioned to a professor that "I still didn't really understand what a force was".  He suggested that perhaps I should be studying something else.  I'm still trying to understand what a force is.Maybe if I had been convinced that forces do not exist I would have had more time to watch television over these past 3 decades.By the way, my efforts in gravitation has been to rewrite Einstein's equations as Newtonian forces.
 Pioneer1 said on June 24, 2007 @ 07:51 PM ( 525 days ago )
Very interesting. I think your professor?s remark means that force needs to be taken as faith in physics. I spent a lot of time trying to understand force as well. My conclusion is that force is nothing other than labels Newton attached to Kepler?s rule as I wrote here http://www.densytics.com/wiki/index.php?title=History_of_G. In this sense force does not exist.I couldn?t find such equations on your site. Although, Einstein started out by denying Newtonian force, apparently he only created a duality in physics. 
 Carl Brannen said on July 12, 2007 @ 05:08 PM ( 507 days ago )
My professor's comment meant that the way you obtain tenure is by fitting in with the rest of the sheep and extending knowledge using only the techniques built from the current assumptions.  He was right of course.  The vast majority of physicists are doing basic engineering using theory that was written by a tiny minority, most of that a long time ago.
 guest said on August 1, 2007 @ 11:54 AM ( 488 days ago )
Well, if mass does exists, so force. Actually, the word "exists", instead of commoner "there is", was created by theologicians to discuss about this kind of topics.
 guest said on August 1, 2007 @ 06:33 PM ( 487 days ago )
Guest, Thanks, for your comment. I believe that both mass and force are definitions invented by Newton and they do not exist. Regarding your comment about "exist" I was trying be careful to use "exist" because I thought it was more scientific because in physics force both exists and exists not. I would appreciate if you explain why it is not good to use "exist" in this context. Thanks.
 Pioneer1 said on August 1, 2007 @ 06:34 PM ( 487 days ago )
Previous comment was by Pioneer1.
 
Leave a Comment :
Poll Details
Created By :Pioneer1
Created Date : 19 Jun 2007
No. of Votes : 9
Last Voted : 01 Aug 2007 11:51 AM
Type : Public
Status : Open
 
Home  Tags  Feedback